FAQ – Greek Restaurant Midtown Manhattan | Butterflied

Question 1

How do I make a reservation?

Accepted Answer

The easiest way is through OpenTable — visit our Reservations page or book directly at opentable.com/butterflied-new-york. You can also call us at 212-652-8764 during business hours. Walk-ins are always welcome based on availability, though we strongly recommend reserving for dinner, especially Thursday through Saturday.

Question 2

What are your hours?

Accepted Answer

Lunch is served Monday through Friday, 12:00 PM – 4:00 PM. Dinner is served Monday through Thursday 5:00 PM – 10:00 PM, and Friday through Sunday 5:00 PM – 11:00 PM. We are open seven days a week for dinner. Hours may vary on major holidays — call ahead or check our website for updates.

Question 3

Do you accept walk-ins?

Accepted Answer

Yes, walk-ins are always welcome. We keep a portion of our dining room available for walk-in guests. That said, dinner service — especially Thursday through Saturday — fills up quickly. For the best experience, we recommend booking in advance through OpenTable.

Question 4

Can I modify or cancel my reservation?

Accepted Answer

Yes. You can modify or cancel through OpenTable up to 2 hours before your reservation time. For same-day changes or cancellations, please call us directly at 212-652-8764 so we can release the table for other guests.

Question 5

How far in advance should I book for a special occasion?

Accepted Answer

For birthdays, anniversaries, and other celebrations, we recommend booking at least 1–2 weeks in advance. For large groups of 8 or more, or for private dining, please reach out as early as possible — ideally 3–4 weeks ahead — to ensure we can accommodate your party and any special requests.

Question 6

Can I request a specific table or seating area?

Accepted Answer

You can note a seating preference in the OpenTable reservation comments (e.g., 'window seat,' 'quiet corner,' 'booth if available'). We do our best to honor requests but cannot guarantee specific tables. If you have an important occasion, mention it and we'll do everything we can to make it special.

Question 7

Do you accommodate large groups?

Accepted Answer

Our main dining room can comfortably seat groups of up to 10. For parties of 11 or more, we recommend inquiring about our private dining options. Please contact us directly at 212-652-8764 or visit our Private Events page to discuss arrangements.

Question 8

Is there a dress code?

Accepted Answer

We have no formal dress code. Smart casual is the norm — most guests dress as they would for a nice dinner out in Midtown Manhattan. We simply ask that you feel comfortable and enjoy yourself.

Question 9

Do you have a cancellation policy?

Accepted Answer

We ask that you cancel at least 2 hours before your reservation time so we can offer the table to other guests. For large parties of 6 or more, we appreciate as much notice as possible. Repeated no-shows may affect future booking eligibility.

Question 10

What kind of cuisine does Butterflied serve?

Accepted Answer

Butterflied serves modern Greek cuisine rooted in authentic Mediterranean tradition. Our menu features mezze (small plates for sharing), grilled meats and seafood, fresh salads, traditional Greek pastries, and classic desserts — all made with high-quality, seasonal ingredients. We also carry an exclusively Greek wine list.

Question 11

What is on the lunch menu?

Accepted Answer

Our lunch menu is available Monday through Friday, 12:00 PM – 4:00 PM. It features lighter Greek fare including mezze, salads, sandwiches, and grilled proteins — all priced between $14 and $22. It's one of the most affordable Greek lunches in Midtown Manhattan, making it a popular choice for business lunches and neighborhood regulars alike.

Question 12

What is on the dinner menu?

Accepted Answer

Our dinner menu is a full expression of Greek cuisine: mezze starters like spanakopita, grilled octopus, and hummus; main courses including lamb, whole fish, and grilled chicken; and desserts like baklava and galaktoboureko. We also offer a Steak Night prix fixe every evening. Dinner is served nightly starting at 5:00 PM.

Question 13

What is Steak Night?

Accepted Answer

Steak Night is our signature prix fixe dinner, available every single night starting at 5:00 PM. For $45 per person, you receive a first course, a main steak dish with sides, and dessert. It's an exceptional value for Midtown Manhattan and one of our most popular offerings. No special reservation is required — just mention Steak Night when you arrive or book.

Question 14

Is Steak Night available every night or only certain days?

Accepted Answer

Steak Night is available every single night of the week, starting at 5:00 PM. There are no blackout dates or day restrictions. Whether it's a Monday or a Saturday, you can always enjoy the three-course prix fixe for $45 per person.

Question 15

Do you have vegetarian or vegan options?

Accepted Answer

Yes. Our menu includes a variety of vegetarian dishes: spanakopita (spinach and feta phyllo), Greek salad, hummus, tzatziki, roasted vegetable plates, and more. For vegan guests, please speak with your server — we can often modify dishes to remove dairy or animal products. We are happy to accommodate dietary needs with advance notice.

Question 16

Can you accommodate gluten-free diners?

Accepted Answer

Many of our dishes are naturally gluten-free, including our grilled proteins, salads, and most mezze. However, our kitchen is not a certified gluten-free facility and cross-contamination is possible. Please inform your server of any gluten sensitivity or celiac disease and we will guide you through the safest options.

Question 17

Do you accommodate other dietary restrictions or allergies?

Accepted Answer

Yes. Please inform your server of any allergies or dietary restrictions when you are seated — or note them in your OpenTable reservation. We take food allergies seriously and will do our best to accommodate you. Common allergens in our kitchen include tree nuts, shellfish, dairy, eggs, and gluten.

Question 18

Do you have a children's menu?

Accepted Answer

We do not have a dedicated children's menu, but many of our dishes are kid-friendly — grilled chicken, pita with hummus, Greek salad, and pasta dishes are popular with younger guests. Our staff is happy to suggest options and accommodate smaller portions on request.

Question 19

Can I bring a birthday cake or outside dessert?

Accepted Answer

You are welcome to bring a cake for a celebration. We ask that you let us know in advance when making your reservation. A small cake-cutting fee may apply. Our team is happy to help make your celebration memorable.

Question 20

Do you offer a tasting menu or chef's menu?

Accepted Answer

We do not currently offer a formal tasting menu. However, for private dining events and large group bookings, we can work with you to create a custom multi-course menu. Contact us at 212-652-8764 or through our Private Events page to discuss options.

Question 21

What is on your wine list?

Accepted Answer

Our wine list is exclusively Greek — one of the most distinctive in New York City. We feature whites like Assyrtiko from Santorini, Moschofilero from the Peloponnese, and Malagousia; a beautiful Amalia Rosé; and reds including Xinomavro from Naoussa and Agiorgitiko from Nemea. Our staff can help you find the perfect pairing for your meal.

Question 22

Why only Greek wines?

Accepted Answer

We believe Greek wines are among the most underappreciated in the world. By focusing exclusively on Greek varietals, we can offer a curated, deeply knowledgeable selection and introduce our guests to wines they may never have tried. It's part of what makes dining at Butterflied a genuinely Greek experience.

Question 23

Do you serve cocktails and spirits?

Accepted Answer

Yes. Our bar offers a full selection of cocktails, including Greek-inspired creations featuring ouzo and mastiha liqueur, as well as classic cocktails, beer, and non-alcoholic options. Ask your server or bartender for our current cocktail menu.

Question 24

Can I bring my own wine (BYOB)?

Accepted Answer

We do not offer BYOB service. We have a full bar and an extensive Greek wine list to complement your meal. Our staff is happy to recommend the perfect bottle for your table.

Question 25

Do you offer wine by the glass?

Accepted Answer

Yes. We offer a rotating selection of Greek wines by the glass, including whites, rosé, and reds. Ask your server for the current by-the-glass list, or let them know your preferences and they'll suggest something you'll love.

Question 26

Is Butterflied good for pre-theater dining?

Accepted Answer

Absolutely. We are located at 18 West 45th Street, steps from virtually every major Broadway and Off-Broadway theater. We specialize in pre-theater dining — tell your server your curtain time and we'll pace your meal so you're out the door in 75 minutes or less, satisfied and on time.

Question 27

How early should I arrive before a Broadway show?

Accepted Answer

We recommend arriving at Butterflied at least 90 minutes before curtain. That gives you a comfortable 75-minute meal plus a 10–15 minute walk to most nearby theaters. Most Broadway houses on 44th and 45th Street are a 3–5 minute walk from our door.

Question 28

Do I need to tell you I have a show when I book?

Accepted Answer

It helps! You can note your curtain time in the OpenTable reservation comments, or simply tell your server when you're seated. We'll pace your courses accordingly so you never feel rushed.

Question 29

Which Broadway theaters are closest to Butterflied?

Accepted Answer

The St. James Theatre (246 W 44th St), Majestic Theatre (245 W 44th St), and Shubert Theatre (225 W 44th St) are all a 3–4 minute walk. The Richard Rodgers Theatre, Lunt-Fontanne, and Booth Theatre are 5 minutes away. The Gershwin Theatre (Wicked) is about 8 minutes north on 51st Street.

Question 30

Is Steak Night a good option before a show?

Accepted Answer

It's one of the best. The three-course Steak Night prix fixe ($45 per person) is perfectly paced for a pre-theater dinner — a satisfying, beautifully structured meal that won't leave you rushing. Just let your server know your curtain time.

Question 31

Do you offer a special pre-theater menu?

Accepted Answer

We do not have a separate abbreviated pre-theater menu — our full dinner menu is available every night. We believe you shouldn't have to compromise on your meal just because you have a show. Our kitchen is experienced at pacing meals for theatergoers.

Question 32

Can I order online for pickup or delivery?

Accepted Answer

Yes. You can order directly through Toast on our Online Order page for the fastest, most accurate experience. We also accept orders through DoorDash, Grubhub, Uber Eats, and Seamless for delivery to your home or office.

Question 33

What is the best way to order for delivery?

Accepted Answer

For delivery, you can use DoorDash, Grubhub, Uber Eats, or Seamless. For pickup, we recommend ordering directly through our website via Toast — it's faster, more accurate, and you avoid third-party fees.

Question 34

What is your delivery radius?

Accepted Answer

Delivery radius and availability depend on the platform you use (DoorDash, Grubhub, Uber Eats, Seamless). Generally, we deliver throughout Midtown Manhattan and surrounding neighborhoods. Check your preferred delivery app for exact availability at your address.

Question 35

Is the online menu the same as the in-restaurant menu?

Accepted Answer

Our online ordering menu features our most popular dishes and is updated regularly. Some items available in the restaurant may not be available for delivery due to packaging or travel considerations. The full menu is always available when dining in.

Question 36

Can I order catering online?

Accepted Answer

For catering orders, please submit an inquiry through our Catering page rather than the standard online ordering system. Our catering team will follow up within one business day to discuss your event, menu, and logistics.

Question 37

Do you offer catering services?

Accepted Answer

Yes. Butterflied offers full-service Greek catering throughout New York City for corporate events, office lunches, weddings, cocktail parties, private dinners, and more. Our catering menu includes mezze spreads, grilled meats, salads, desserts, and beverage packages.

Question 38

What types of events do you cater?

Accepted Answer

We cater a wide range of events: corporate lunches and dinners, office parties, team celebrations, wedding receptions, rehearsal dinners, birthday parties, cocktail receptions, and holiday gatherings. Whether it's 20 people or 200, we can create a menu and service plan that fits your event.

Question 39

What is the minimum guest count for catering?

Accepted Answer

Our standard catering packages are designed for groups of 20 or more. For smaller gatherings, please contact us directly — we may be able to accommodate smaller orders depending on availability and event type.

Question 40

How do I request a catering quote?

Accepted Answer

Visit our Catering page and submit an inquiry form with your event date, guest count, location, and any special requirements. Our catering team will follow up within one business day with menu options and pricing.

Question 41

How far in advance should I book catering?

Accepted Answer

We recommend booking catering at least 2–3 weeks in advance for most events. For large events (100+ guests) or events requiring custom menus, 4–6 weeks is ideal. Last-minute requests are accommodated when possible — contact us directly.

Question 42

Do you offer on-site catering staff?

Accepted Answer

Yes. Our full-service catering packages include professional staff for setup, service, and breakdown. We can also provide drop-off catering for events where you prefer to self-serve. Details are discussed during the booking process.

Question 43

Can I host a private event at the restaurant?

Accepted Answer

Yes. We offer private dining at Butterflied for corporate dinners, birthday celebrations, rehearsal dinners, client entertainment, and other special occasions. Our private dining space can be configured for various group sizes. Visit our Private Events page to submit an inquiry.

Question 44

What private event types do you accommodate?

Accepted Answer

We host corporate dinners, birthday and anniversary celebrations, rehearsal dinners, holiday parties, client entertainment, team dinners, and more. We can customize the menu, décor, and service style to match your event's needs.

Question 45

Do you offer custom menus for private events?

Accepted Answer

Yes. For private dining and catering events, we work with you to create a custom menu that reflects your preferences, dietary needs, and budget. Our team can suggest Greek-inspired menus ranging from casual mezze spreads to elegant multi-course dinners.

Question 46

Do you have a loyalty or rewards program?

Accepted Answer

Yes. Butterflied has a loyalty rewards program powered by Toast. You earn points on every qualifying purchase — dining in, ordering online, or ordering for delivery through our direct channel. Points can be redeemed for discounts on future visits.

Question 47

How do I sign up for the rewards program?

Accepted Answer

You can sign up through our Rewards page on this website, or by creating an account through Toast when you place an online order. You can also ask your server to enroll you during your next visit.

Question 48

How do I earn points?

Accepted Answer

You earn points on every qualifying purchase at Butterflied — whether you dine in, order online for pickup, or order through our direct Toast channel. Points are automatically added to your account when you use your registered email or phone number at checkout.

Question 49

How do I redeem my rewards?

Accepted Answer

Rewards can be redeemed at checkout when dining in (mention your account to your server) or when placing an online order through Toast. Visit our Rewards page for current redemption tiers and available offers.

Question 50

Do rewards points expire?

Accepted Answer

Points expiration policies are managed through Toast. Please check your rewards account or contact us at 212-652-8764 for the most current information on point expiration and program terms.

Question 51

Where is Butterflied located?

Accepted Answer

We are located at 18 West 45th Street, Midtown Manhattan, New York, NY 10036 — between Fifth Avenue and Sixth Avenue, one block north of Bryant Park. We are steps from the Theater District and a short walk from Grand Central Terminal.

Question 52

What subway lines are nearby?

Accepted Answer

We are conveniently served by multiple subway lines. The B, D, F, and M trains stop at 42nd Street–Bryant Park (2-minute walk). The 4, 5, 6, and 7 trains stop at Grand Central–42nd Street (5-minute walk). The N, Q, R, and W trains stop at Times Square–42nd Street (5-minute walk).

Question 53

Is there parking nearby?

Accepted Answer

Street parking is extremely limited in Midtown Manhattan. We recommend arriving by subway, taxi, or rideshare. Several parking garages are located within a few blocks, including options on 44th and 46th Streets. Apps like SpotHero or ParkWhiz can help you find and reserve a spot in advance.

Question 54

Is the restaurant wheelchair accessible?

Accepted Answer

Yes, Butterflied is wheelchair accessible. Our entrance and dining room accommodate wheelchairs and mobility devices. If you have specific accessibility needs or require assistance, please let us know when making your reservation and we will ensure you are comfortably accommodated.

Question 55

Is Butterflied near Bryant Park?

Accepted Answer

Yes — we are one block north of Bryant Park, making us a perfect dining destination before or after a Bryant Park event, ice skating, or a stroll through the park. We're also steps from the New York Public Library on Fifth Avenue.

Question 56

How close are you to Times Square?

Accepted Answer

We are approximately a 5-minute walk from Times Square. Our location on 45th Street between Fifth and Sixth Avenues puts us right in the heart of Midtown, close to Times Square but away from the most congested tourist areas — making us a great choice for a quieter, more authentic dining experience.

Question 57

Do you have outdoor seating?

Accepted Answer

Outdoor seating availability varies by season. Please call us at 212-652-8764 or check when making your reservation to confirm current outdoor seating options.

Question 58

Is Butterflied good for a business lunch?

Accepted Answer

Absolutely. Our Midtown location, professional atmosphere, and affordable lunch menu ($14–$22) make us one of the best options for business lunches in the area. We're a short walk from major Midtown offices, Grand Central, and Bryant Park. Lunch is served Monday through Friday, 12:00 PM – 4:00 PM.

Frequently Asked Questions

Reservations & Hours

Menus & Dining

Wine, Drinks & Bar

Pre-Theater & Special Experiences

Online Ordering & Delivery

Catering & Private Events

Loyalty Program & Rewards

Location, Parking & Accessibility

Quick Reference

Hours

Location

Subway

Contact

Still have questions?